Village Counseling Center, Family & Marriage Counseling in Arroyo Grande, San Luis Obispo, Santa Maria.
HomeCounselingCoachingSeminarsInsuranceFAQsLocationsContact Us

How To Motivate Men

by Clay Watkins, LMFT

The article below appeared in The Women's Press and was written by Clay Watkins, a staff therapist at Village Counseling Center in Arroyo Grande, California. It is somewhat tongue-in-cheek, but there is also much truth in it as well.

As a marriage and family therapist, women often ask me how to motivate the males in their lives. They regale me with vivid descriptions of the elaborate schemes they use to no avail, ones involving simple requests, begging, nagging, even withholding of sex. And whether the issue is getting their son to take out the trash, persuading their boyfriend to propose, or convincing their husband to stop asking the kids to pull his finger, it always centers around the same wrong assumption; that men mature at the same rate women do.

Now most of us realize little girls and boys mature at different rates in our society. Whether due to genetics or socialization, girls are generally first to grasp the complexities of relationships, the ambiguities of morals and ethics, the intricacies of personal hygiene. The mistake women often make when addressing adult male behavior, however, is assuming men eventually catch up to them in the maturity department. It is difficult to emphasize how fully incorrect this assumption is. Let’s just say it is akin to expecting a Shetland pony to catch up with a thoroughbred. It will never happen.

Feel free to ask any man about this. They will all back me up. Maturity just doesn’t come naturally to us, ladies. We see the need for it, we may even attempt it occasionally, but for some reason it just doesn’t compute for us. Just like when you verbally explain to your puppy how important it is for him to poop on the paper instead of the carpet, when you ask us men to be adults, all we can do is sit and look at you with loveable, glassy eyes. Maturity? Appropriate behavior? Hmmm. Yeah. Sorry. Could you spell it?

You see, American males hold many concepts dear; the importance of democracy, the value of a free capitalist market, the need for a balanced distribution of skills in society. In fact, we believe this last concept applies to male-female relationships specifically, and stands as a cornerstone to our resistance to all things responsible. To elaborate, we men consider it an inefficient relational model to create redundant strengths within a couple. And since women have a natural propensity toward maturity in relationships, it seems to us only reasonable to let you be the leaders in that category. Our reasoning goes even one step further: it would be downright wasteful for us men to expend energy duplicating that maturity thing. No use reinventing the wheel, right? Moreover, this logical allocation of responsibility has the inherent benefit of allowing us men to concentrate on perfecting those skills by which we come more naturally, like burping, or passing the car in front of us, or racing at top speed through television channels.

To motivate men, therefore, one must first accept this basic supposition, that for a society to be productive, men must be treated like boys. We’re not proud of it, but we all accept it.

A second supposition is just as crucial; that we men do not like being told what to do. We will, in fact, make it our main goal in life to do the exact opposite of what we are told to do, even when it is to our detriment to do so. Now when my teen clients exhibit this behavior, I label it Oppositional Defiant Disorder. When the husband of a client shows this tendency, however, I just call it gender normal.

Finally, I submit a related mixed-metaphor axiom; that members of the male gender respond better to carrots than they do to switches. I think I can speak with some experience, that to understand the conundrum that is the male mind, one must grasp the value of positive rewards over the use of punishment, at least in regard to motivating or changing a man’s behavior. Let’s face it, superficial obedience is the best result one can expect from solely applying punishment to manipulate an adult male. Like the little boy in the back of the bus says while compliantly sitting after being forcefully told to do so by the bus driver, most men will respond by saying, “I may be sitting on the outside, but I’m standing on the inside!”

So moving on from these underlying beliefs, how does one actually motivate men to change, improve, or at least quit armpit-farting in public? Ah, Grasshopper, it is simpler than you may have imagined.

First, a few things to avoid:

  1. Never ask men for a personality change. Be content if our behavior changes. If you are patient, our personality will mold itself around our behavior; it just takes a while.
  2. Do not ask us men to feel the way you do as a precursor to change. Men’s emotions are the caboose on the train, not the engine. And don’t ask why this is. We don’t understand it either. My sense is that it has to do with double helixes and deoxyribonucleic acid, but I could be wrong.

Second, some ideas on how to motivate men:

  1. Realize the importance of the male ego and use it to your advantage. This is not manipulative as much as it is merely realistic. A man will never change unless he can do so with his self-image intact. Use the Oreo approach; enclose the essence of your request in the tasty cookie of a compliment. “Honey, as good as you are at fixing things around the house, do you think you could oil that squeaky door in the bedroom? I know you’re busy, but I also know how important it is to you to keep everything working just right.” Sure, it’s corny and an obvious use of flattery, but just try it. Chances are good he won’t notice. Remember, you’re not working with an adult; you’re working with a child in an adult body.
  2. When a man does something you want or have asked him to do, ask how he did it. We men love to explain our successes. And the more we feel we have succeeded at an activity, the more likely we are to repeat it. You say (sans even a hint of sarcasm), “Honey, I noticed you picked up all your socks yesterday and put them in the hamper. What made you do that?” Now he is free to elucidate on the complexities of how he decisively chose to move down the path of personal cleanliness. Listen with a straight face and you will reap long-lasting behavioral rewards.
  3. Use his natural opposition to motivate him. This should not be confused with shaming a man into doing what you want, which, though effective in the short-term, is not a useful long-term solution. We men often need to push against something to get motivated. We are warriors in search of an enemy against whom to fight. By stating your opinion on something your man has (or has not) done, you provide him a stable position, a starting block, from which to initiate his movement toward a goal. Similar to the reverse psychology of the 1960s, therapists now label this type of intervention strategic. When your husband ignores subtle hints or direct requests to fix the side gate, you say, “Sweetie, I’ve been thinking that broken gate may be too difficult for you to fix by yourself, so I scheduled a fix-it man to come on Monday to repair it.” It may not work, but then again it might. The key, again, is to deliver your lines without the least bit of sarcasm, letting his natural motivation fuel his actions.

Certainly there are many more ways of motivating men than can be covered in a short article such as this, but these suggestions should get you started. It may not be possible for women to ever fully understand men, but it is possible for the genders to work effectively together, as long as the women of the world are willing to be patient, and put up with an occasional noisy bodily function or two.

Clay Watkins is a licensed marriage and family therapist and specializes in men’s and couples issues.

All contents © 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004 Village Counseling

Our director, Clay Watkins, M.A. LMFT, a licensed Marriage & Family Therapist. Our director, Clay Watkins, LMFT, is a licensed Marriage and Family Therapist. He provides individual, couples and family counseling. He specializes in anxiety-related difficulties including panic attacks, post-traumatic stress (PTSD) and phobias. He has advanced training and a decade of experience utilizing EMDR to treat trauma, and his unique brand of counseling integrates a solution-focused perspective that often speeds up the therapy process compared to more traditional forms of counseling. (BBS License #: MFC 37239)
Clay's Curriculum Vitae

Clay coordinates referrals to a network of experienced and qualified counselors with a variety of specialties to meet your specific needs. Contact him today and start creating a better life for you and your family.

Philosophy

At Village Counseling Center we believe most people have the resources to solve their problems. At times, however, a trauma or broken relationships or even the normal pressures of life can cause us to lose sight of our strengths; obscuring our natural ability to problem solve. Counseling provides a safe place where clients can regain their perspective, find acceptance, and challenge themselves to grow. And though true growth does require significant effort and courage, we at Village Counseling Center believe happiness is worth the price. Call us and begin building a better life, one risk at a time.

Learn more about Solution-Focused Therapy

Learn more about EMDR and the treatment of trauma, fear and anxiety